STILL PAYING RENT
← Back to the ArchiveFictional disaster file
1976 / Music / War

Billy Joel: Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway)

You remember the luncheonette more than the skyline.

Billy Joel: Miami 2017 official audio thumbnail
Billy Joel · Official audio artwork ↗

Spoilers for Billy Joel: Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) (1976). Includes major plot events and the ending.

Imagine you’re there · An original NYC side story

You start with the skyline when you tell the story. Everybody expects the skyline. Then you find yourself describing a luncheonette off Flatbush Avenue nobody listening has heard of.

In this imagined future, New York burned and its familiar landmarks fell. You got out. Years later, you can still explain which train you used to take, although there is no practical reason for anyone to know.

Your listener asks what it was like watching the lights go out on Broadway. You give the big answer first. Then the small one: you kept expecting someone to restore them.

There are things you remember perfectly and things you invent by accident. Another former New Yorker corrects your directions halfway through.

For a moment, it feels like home.

The final verdict

Your survival rating

20%

Leave with a story to tell.

The song describes large-scale destruction with survivors looking back. The score concerns living through the collapse, not the quieter life afterward.

Your survival tip: Apparently the evacuation plan was Florida.

What this rating assumes

Ordinary person, visitor or resident, with no superpowers, in the listed affected area when the crisis begins. Citywide exposure lowers this editorial score by 10 points. This score applies only to the alternate or future setting described in this entry.

Our fictional survival score, for entertainment. Not a scientific probability or an audience vote.